从一种19世纪手动机关炮可以判断戴梓机枪的可能性

我只是个南北战争武器爱好者，也喜欢太平天国。很多军工细节我并不懂。这是偶然看到的一个介绍。


前几年大家人云亦云，说戴梓在十八世纪初发明了机枪，說戴晚上做了个梦，梦里，老天让他仁慈，所以他没有将该机枪推广什么什么的

其实你如果看看下面这款19世纪50年代的barnes机关炮设计的艰难。
你就应该知道戴那个年代（十八世纪）不可能设计出手动机枪

其实，目前大家都更认可的是，戴是模仿了英国人送给康熙的一款早期不实用的后膛枪（缺点很多，射程非常短，装蛋过程程序复杂，结构复杂不适合大量生产）。

A French researcher, Abbé J. Rouquette. In the archives of the province of Languedoc at Montpellier he found a curious and interesting document. This stated thata man who called himself Abraham Soyer was picked up on some minor charge, and brought before Abbé du Chayla, archpriest and inspector of the mission of the Cevennes.
In the prisoner's luggage was found a small weapon that he was carrying to St. Etienne to turn over to the gunsmiths there as a working model. Evidently this was Soyer's idea of the way to get the gun into production. If the additional information given is correct, the weapon was indeed a clever firing device for that day. It is alleged to have had a breech that allowed it to be loaded through the butt end of the stock (using, perhaps, some crude cartridge to accomplish this). A clear description was not given in the records. The reason can well be imagined when the nature of the device and the troubled times are taken into consideration.
这段欧洲的记载说明了这枪的大概来历

里面这个并不详细的描述至少说明这只枪是从枪托装蛋。和进贡给康熙的那只琵琶枪托后装枪一样。


戴那个年代（十八世纪初），无论你如何天才，也不可能发明实用的机枪。
原因很简单，两点：没有雷汞。没有定装蛋。

散装发射药和燧发点火装置是不可能实现机枪的



我只是个南北战争武器爱好者，也喜欢太平天国。很多军工细节我并不懂。这是偶然看到的一个介绍。


前几年大家人云亦云，说戴梓在十八世纪初发明了机枪，說戴晚上做了个梦，梦里，老天让他仁慈，所以他没有将该机枪推广什么什么的

其实你如果看看下面这款19世纪50年代的barnes机关炮设计的艰难。
你就应该知道戴那个年代（十八世纪）不可能设计出手动机枪

其实，目前大家都更认可的是，戴是模仿了英国人送给康熙的一款早期不实用的后膛枪（缺点很多，射程非常短，装蛋过程程序复杂，结构复杂不适合大量生产）。

A French researcher, Abbé J. Rouquette. In the archives of the province of Languedoc at Montpellier he found a curious and interesting document. This stated thata man who called himself Abraham Soyer was picked up on some minor charge, and brought before Abbé du Chayla, archpriest and inspector of the mission of the Cevennes.
In the prisoner's luggage was found a small weapon that he was carrying to St. Etienne to turn over to the gunsmiths there as a working model. Evidently this was Soyer's idea of the way to get the gun into production. If the additional information given is correct, the weapon was indeed a clever firing device for that day. It is alleged to have had a breech that allowed it to be loaded through the butt end of the stock (using, perhaps, some crude cartridge to accomplish this). A clear description was not given in the records. The reason can well be imagined when the nature of the device and the troubled times are taken into consideration.
这段欧洲的记载说明了这枪的大概来历

里面这个并不详细的描述至少说明这只枪是从枪托装蛋。和进贡给康熙的那只琵琶枪托后装枪一样。


戴那个年代（十八世纪初），无论你如何天才，也不可能发明实用的机枪。
原因很简单，两点：没有雷汞。没有定装蛋。

散装发射药和燧发点火装置是不可能实现机枪的